Index Concentration at a Crossroads: Nvidia and the Risk of Rebalance
Calisade Capital is an asset management firm that delivers institutional advisory services and weekly insights to the retail market via its Calisade Digests. Calisade focuses on creating alpha through robust macro, fundamental, technical, and sentiment research.
Introduction
This week’s Digest examines the growing challenge of equity market concentration. The dominance of Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, and their peers has pushed index weights to historic extremes, with the top ten companies now controlling more than 30% of the S&P 500 and the top five making up over 40% of the Nasdaq 100. Such levels strain diversification rules and raise the prospect of forced rebalancing. Our focus is on how concentration builds, why index committees may intervene, and what this means for investors navigating markets shaped by a handful of mega caps.
The Concentration Disconnect
Indices like the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq 100 were designed to capture the breadth of U.S. business. Yet in 2025, a handful of companies account for a disproportionate share of returns. The top ten S&P 500 constituents now represent more than 30% of market cap, surpassing prior peaks in 2000 and 2020. In the Nasdaq 100, the top five control nearly 42% of the index, a new record. Nvidia stands out with an 8% weight in the S&P 500 and 10% in the Nasdaq 100. What looks like strength on the surface may in fact signal fragility beneath, as passive funds are pulled to the edges of diversification limits.
Why Index Rules Matter
Concentration is not just about optics. Regulatory thresholds such as the 5 10 40 rule force funds to maintain diversification. If the combined weight of companies above 5% of an index surpasses 40%, index providers must step in. This has happened before: in 2011, Apple’s surge to nearly 20% of the Nasdaq 100 forced a special rebalance, cutting its weight to 12% and triggering tens of billions of dollars in forced flows. The mechanics matter because ETFs and index funds have no discretion, they must track whatever the index committee decides. For investors, that means structural flows can suddenly overwhelm fundamentals.
Real-World Cases
History offers several guideposts. IBM in the 1970s held such sway over the S&P 500 that markets were dubbed a one-stock show. Apple in 2011 forced Nasdaq’s hand and underperformed for months afterward despite strong fundamentals. Today, Nvidia’s dual dominance across both indices is unique. Passive ownership accounts for roughly a quarter of its free float, amplifying the risk that any rebalance unleashes large mechanical selling. Alphabet, Microsoft, and Apple all sit close enough to regulatory thresholds that they too could be drawn into adjustments. Together, the Magnificent 7 now represents over 40% of the Nasdaq 100, an unprecedented concentration that makes a replay of earlier episodes more likely.
Signals We’re Watching
- Nvidia’s weight drifting toward 15% of the Nasdaq 100, a level that has triggered action in past cycles.
- Top ten S&P 500 constituents holding above 30% of market cap and still rising.
- ETF ownership share of Nvidia, Apple, and Microsoft, which reduces discretionary absorption capacity.
- The relative performance gap between cap-weighted and equal-weighted indices, a measure of concentration stress.
- Any index committee statements or methodological updates hinting at special rebalances.
Want to Go Deeper?
Our Premium Digest expands this summary into a full 15-page research report on index concentration. It covers historical precedents like IBM, Microsoft, and Apple, the mechanics of index construction, regulatory triggers such as the 5-10-40 rule, and predictive scenarios for today’s mega caps including Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, and Alphabet.
Our Elite Digest goes further, adding in-depth historical case studies such as the 1998 Nasdaq leaders and ExxonMobil in the 1980s, extended systemic risk analysis of passive ownership and liquidity fragility, and a stock-level watchlist highlighting potential beneficiaries or casualties of rebalancing.
📩 Click to explore Premium or Elite Access and see what top investors are reading.
